35 replies to this topic

[Fish Fan10]

Profar, Olt, and 1 off Texas top pitching prospects?

[Piazza31]

No

[gizmo]

We might not get a better offer.

[MarlinKidd101]

No

[Piazza31]

I say we sign Mike Stanton, and make the Stanton trade talks interesting.

[Piazza31]

We might not get a better offer.

Than you go 4 more years with him in RF and trade him for what you can get or take the compensation pick.

If he's still hitting like he has in 2015 his value will hold.

[el penguino]

Profar, Olt, and 1 off Texas top pitching prospects?

If the Marlins cannot sign him to an extension for a reasonable amount, then yes.

[Bret Hart]

NO

[yokofox33]

I'd rather keep him, but that would be the only package I'd be content with if we did trade him.

[el penguino]

I'd rather keep him, but that would be the only package I'd be content with if we did trade him.

Well, we all know that signing him for 10 years/$200 million is plan A.

[Erick]

No, it would take more than that. 

[Fish Fan10]

I'm on the fence... By the time we are ready to compete Stanton will be outta here! When Texas signed Berkman it meant both profar and Olt will be in minors again. Both seem like future all stars... But then again I think Stanton is a once in ten year kinda player.

[squall]

4 years 100 mil with a 10 year buyout option worth 300 mil. 200 mil bonus if he's mixed race.

[Retro_Marlins]

+ elvis andrus and I say yes

[pollyvonwog]

why don't we just trade ricky nolasco for profar and olt?

[Hotcorner]

Ricky is good friends with Greg Dobbs.

[Dr Beinfest]

why don't we just trade ricky nolasco for profar and olt?

 

How many wins do Profar and Olt have again? It would take more than that.

[canefandynasty]

Profar and Olt are incredibly overrated prospects IMO

[Wild Card]

Honestly, I think Texas has already made an offer for Stanton that includes Profar and Olt. There's a reason the rumors are so frequent, because a deal with these players and teams makes too much sense. But the bottom line is that's just not enough to move Stanton, not with 4 more years of club control. Now, if this were a Miguel Cabrera situation and he only had 2 years left and we know we can't sign him, then I would probably find it to be a fair offer. But since that's not the case, no, I don't make that deal.

[BenderRobot]

When Texas signed Berkman it meant both profar and Olt will be in minors again.

What correlation does the Berkman signing have to do with Profar and Olt's position on a major league roster? Berkman will most likely DH or play first, neither spot which Profar or Olt would occupy. The reason they'd be in the minors would be because of Andrus/Kinsler and Beltre, respectively, and even then, they've had Olt in the outfield, I'm sure with Hamilton gone, they may try the same with Profar a little bit just to get him playing time.

[Dr Beinfest]

Stupid, Profar and Olt are 1B and DH respectively. 

 

Berkman is fat so he occupies both spots in the lineup. 

[BenderRobot]

Once again, Dr Beinfest, you have shown me the error of my ways. Thank you.

[el penguino]

why don't we just trade ricky nolasco for profar and olt?

Because Nolasco is the centerpiece in our trade for Vernon Wells.

[Retro_Marlins]

Im glad im not the only one that feels profar is at least somewhat overrated

[poptart]

profar? i just met har