28 replies to this topic

[Benched]

Morrison has begun working out on a treadmill, which means he's on track for a comeback. It's unlikely Morrison will be ready for opening day. He's uncertain when he'll begin hitting, and said he's not going to play if he has any doubt that his knee is ready.

 

Joe Mahoney: 5-14 (.357), 2 HR, 5 RBI, 1 BB, 3 K

Casey Kotchman: 4-7 (.571), 1 HR, 5 RBI, 1 BB, 0 K

 

Seems like Mahoney is getting more starts and playing time but Kotchman is right there with him in quality of play early on.

 

Who would you give the edge to? Who would you like to see in the OD lineup if Morrison can't go?

[Larry]

I'd rather see Kotchman get the job.

[Benched]

I'd rather see Kotchman get the job.

If he can do what he did in '11, definitely. Somehow I think we'd get the '12 version, though.

 

Mahoney was mediocre in AAA last year though so I'm with you.

[hardw0od]

Still a little too early to tell, but if I had to pick one I'd go with Kotchmann

[squall]

Kotch

[SilverBullet1929]

Plus Kotch has less playing time just cuz he was set back a week with the finger injury. I'd rather have Kotch and just use Mahoney as AAA depth, which we'll probably need anyways eventually.

[anotherrealfan]

Plus Kotch has less playing time just cuz he was set back a week with the finger injury. I'd rather have Kotch and just use Mahoney as AAA depth, which we'll probably need anyways eventually.

And if Mahoney does real well in the minors, we can move up the rankings of minor league systems and maybe be ranked #1 if we win the coaches poll.  Do we get a banner if we do?

[BenderRobot]

Kotchman also has a better glove.

[Larry]

Mahoney is on the 40-man and Kotchman isn't, don't know if that will wind up a factor

[gizmo]

Mahoney is on the 40-man and Kotchman isn't, don't know if that will wind up a factor

 

If Kotchman keeps performing well in Spring, they'll make room for him. 

[Erick]

They should both make the team. 

[Benched]

Mahoney is on the 40-man and Kotchman isn't, don't know if that will wind up a factor

So are a bunch of guys who won't make the team (Cox, Olmos, Caminero, Ceda, Dyson, Lara, Ozuna, Gorkys, Jensen, etc) so that shouldn't be a problem.

[Larry]

Mahoney is on the 40-man and Kotchman isn't, don't know if that will wind up a factor

So are a bunch of guys who won't make the team (Cox, Olmos, Caminero, Ceda, Dyson, Lara, Ozuna, Gorkys, Jensen, etc) so that shouldn't be a problem.

 

If Mahoney and Kotchman have similar numbers. it could wind up a factor.

 

Lara (due to Rule 5) and Gorkys may make it.

[pierremvp1]

It's classic that this season begins with trying to figure out who's on first.

[Erick]

 

Mahoney is on the 40-man and Kotchman isn't, don't know if that will wind up a factor

So are a bunch of guys who won't make the team (Cox, Olmos, Caminero, Ceda, Dyson, Lara, Ozuna, Gorkys, Jensen, etc) so that shouldn't be a problem.

 

If Mahoney and Kotchman have similar numbers. it could wind up a factor.

 

Lara (due to Rule 5) and Gorkys may make it.

 

Lara stinks. 

[Larry]

I have a bias when it comes to the name Lara.

[Piazza31]

It's classic that this season begins with trying to figure out who's on first.

Yeah, but what piece of **** will be on second?

[BenderRobot]

It's classic that this season begins with trying to figure out who's on first.

Yeah, but what piece of **** will be on second?

I just wanna know the player on third, cause, well, I don't know.

[el penguino]

Regardless of whoever wins the starting job, the Marlins fan loses.

[BenderRobot]

But baseball people win.

[Retro_Marlins]

I think it will be kotchman.I think Morrison gets traded.

[Marlins Phenom]

They should sign Jose Abreu from Cuba when they get here for the 2nd rd

[QbanCastillo]

They should sign Jose Abreu from Cuba when they get here for the 2nd rd

 

If by here you mean Miami, then that won't happen. Cuba plays in Tokyo in the 2nd Round. No way the Cuban government would allow the team to play in Miami and, btw, Abreu's natural position is outfield.

[Hotcorner]

Erick, on 03 Mar 2013 - 17:13, said:
They should both make the team.

so with Lomo out (and assume Silverio is DL), think it's Kotch for 1B and then bench is ...

Mahoney, Skip, Figgins, Petersen, Gorkys...?


maybe use Kearns instead of one of Petey/Gorkys. Both of those guys can play CF if needed but since neither can hit there's probably no point in keeping both. I think Kotch/Mahoney can play a little LF/RF when needed.

 

someone's going to get a lot of at-bats backing up at 3B, Polanco's back already hurts.

So many great options to pick from!

[Benched]

Erick, on 03 Mar 2013 - 17:13, said:
They should both make the team.

so with Lomo out (and assume Silverio is DL), think it's Kotch for 1B and then bench is ...

Mahoney, Skip, Figgins, Petersen, Gorkys...?


maybe use Kearns instead of one of Petey/Gorkys. Both of those guys can play CF if needed but since neither can hit there's probably no point in keeping both. I think Kotch/Mahoney can play a little LF/RF when needed.

So many great options to pick from.

Figgins is god awful. I really hope he doesn't make this team. I'd much rather have Kouzmanoff on the roster. Even Cox would probably be better.